Entra PIM Vs MIM PAM: The Three Buckets That Decide A Bastion Forest Retirement

Entra PIM Vs MIM PAM: The Three Buckets That Decide A Bastion Forest Retirement

The question behind every MIM PAM review

Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) 2016 leaves extended support on January 10, 2029. Teams that deployed MIM Privileged Access Management (PAM) years ago now have to decide what takes over the request, approve, elevate, expire cycle for their administrators. The obvious candidate is Microsoft Entra Privileged Identity Management (PIM), and the obvious question is whether it fully replaces MIM PAM. Azure IAM, LLC, an independent identity consulting firm that moves MIM estates to SailPoint IdentityIQ and Microsoft Entra ID, answers that question role by role rather than product by product. The firm's MIM exit method is published at https://azureiam.com/mim-to-sailpoint.

Two products, two different places

MIM PAM lives entirely on premises. A dedicated PRIV forest holds shadow principals for the privileged groups in the production CORP forest. When an administrator's elevation request is approved by a MIM workflow, the MIM Service adds a separate administrative account to the shadow group with a time limit. Active Directory issues a Kerberos ticket that carries the CORP group's SID, and the membership expires inside the directory without anyone removing it. Microsoft now describes MIM PAM as intended for isolated Active Directory environments without Internet access, configurations required by regulation, and disconnected operational technology, and says it is not recommended for new deployments in Internet-connected environments.

Entra PIM lives in the cloud. A user is made eligible for a Microsoft Entra role, an Azure resource role, or membership or ownership of a security group. Activation requires whatever the policy demands: approval, multifactor authentication, justification, a capped duration. Notifications, access reviews, and downloadable audit history come with it. Entra PIM adds the active assignment within seconds and removes it within seconds when the window closes.

The two products overlap on the workflow and differ on where the privilege is enforced. That difference is the whole answer.

Bucket one: roles that move straight to PIM

Any MIM PAM role that gated cloud rights never belonged in a bastion forest. Global Administrator, Exchange Administrator, Intune roles, and Azure subscription Owner or Contributor are first class citizens in PIM for Microsoft Entra roles and PIM for Azure resources. Cloud-created security groups, including role-assignable groups used to grant Entra roles, go into PIM for Groups with one policy for membership activation and another for ownership.

Azure IAM treats this bucket as a configuration exercise. The MIM PAM role definitions become eligible assignments, the MIM approval policy becomes a PIM activation policy, and the bastion forest stops being involved.

Bucket two: Active Directory application groups

Most MIM PAM roles in a Contoso-style estate protect application and server administration groups in the CORP forest: SQL administrators, file server operators, the group that can log on to a particular tier of servers. These groups can move, with one architectural change.

PIM for Groups cannot manage a group that was synchronized from on-premises Active Directory, and it cannot manage dynamic groups. So the existing Active Directory group is not brought into PIM. Instead a new cloud security group is created in Entra ID, or the existing synchronized group has its source of authority converted to the cloud. Microsoft Entra Cloud Sync then provisions that cloud group into Active Directory Domain Services with Universal scope and keeps its membership aligned. The application is repointed to the new group's SID or distinguished name, or the new group is nested inside the group the application already checks. Group Writeback v2 in Entra Connect Sync is deprecated for this purpose; Cloud Sync is the supported route.

With that in place, PIM for Groups handles eligibility, approval, and expiry on the cloud group, and Cloud Sync writes the membership to Active Directory on its provisioning cycle. Microsoft's guidance adds a control worth copying from MIM PAM: configure directory monitoring so that only the group managed service account running the provisioning agent is authorized to change membership in the provisioned group.

Three limits apply. A group with Global scope has to change to Universal before it can hold the provisioned group. A provisioned group holds no more than 50,000 members. Every user eligible in PIM for Groups needs a Microsoft Entra ID P2 or Microsoft Entra ID Governance license.

Bucket three: tier zero, where PIM is not the answer

The groups MIM PAM was created to protect are the ones the cloud path excludes. Microsoft's Cloud Sync documentation lists Domain Admins, Enterprise Admins, Schema Admins, Group Policy Creator Owners, Key Admins, Enterprise Key Admins, Protected Users, Domain Guests, and Domain Users as groups that cannot be used by Cloud Sync. An application or process that checks Domain Admins membership has to be changed to check a new group instead, which is reasonable for an application and unworkable for the directory itself.

The enforcement model changes too. MIM PAM's expiry is a property of the Active Directory membership and the Kerberos ticket. On the PIM path, the cloud assignment expires within seconds but the Active Directory membership changes when Cloud Sync next runs, and an application that cached a group membership may keep honoring it until the user signs in again. For application groups that is acceptable. For domain controller administration it is a different control, and it has to be assessed as one.

Isolated forests close the list. A plant network, a disconnected research forest, or a regulated enclave with no Internet path cannot reach Entra PIM at all. Microsoft's remaining supported use case for MIM PAM is precisely the case PIM cannot serve.

For bucket three, Azure IAM points clients to Microsoft's securing privileged access guidance, which rests on tiering, privileged access workstations, and dedicated administrative accounts, and to a dedicated on-premises privileged access product where the environment demands a vault and session control. Keeping MIM PAM running past January 10, 2029 without vendor support is a documented risk decision, not a plan.

Rules that surprise teams during the move

  • Once a group is managed by PIM for Groups it cannot be taken out of management.
  • Role-assignable groups cannot have other groups nested inside them as active members, although a group can be an eligible member of another group.
  • Groups in Restricted Management Administrative Units are not supported in PIM.
  • Assignments cannot be shorter than five minutes or removed within five minutes of creation.
  • MIM PAM approvals that depended on Microsoft Entra Multifactor Authentication Server lost that factor on September 30, 2024, so a PAM estate that never remediated it has been approving elevation without a second factor since then.

Eligibility is a governance decision, not an elevation feature

Whichever tool performs the activation, someone decides who is eligible to request it and reviews that list. In a MIM to SailPoint IdentityIQ migration, Azure IAM moves that decision into IdentityIQ. Privileged groups and the accounts eligible for them become entitlements subject to access certification campaigns and separation of duties policy, so the elevation roster is certified with the rest of the estate. PIM activates; IdentityIQ decides and reviews. That split holds for bucket one and bucket two today, and it holds for whatever product ends up protecting bucket three.

Sorting the roles before the deadline

The exercise that settles the headline question is a spreadsheet, not a product comparison. Every MIM PAM role is listed with the CORP groups it shadows, the systems that check those groups, and the connectivity of the forest they live in. Roles that gate cloud rights go to PIM. Roles that gate application groups in a connected forest go to Cloud Sync provisioned groups under PIM for Groups. Roles that gate protected groups or live in isolated forests get their own decision, owner, and date. Only then does the bastion forest get a decommission plan: removing PAM roles, shadow principals, and the PRIV to CORP trust in a planned change window, because a bastion forest left running without updates is a privileged attack surface of its own.

Azure IAM scopes MIM exits, Privileged Access Management included, on a fixed fee, and offers a consultation at https://azureiam.com/contact.


Azure IAM, LLC
City: Las Cruces
Address: 2521 North Main
Website: https://azureiam.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The 10 Biggest Challenges in E-Commerce in 2024

WordPress Optimization Checklist: What Business Owners Miss That Kills Leads

The 13th Annual SEO Rockstars Is Set For Its 2024 Staging: Get Your Tickets Here