How to Choose a Food Marketing Agency That Won't Leave You Stranded

Food manufacturers face a critical crossroads when scaling nationally. Building internal sales teams requires years of investment and expertise that most companies cannot afford. Partnering with the wrong agency creates dependencies that can devastate a business. Understanding how to evaluate food marketing agency options prevents costly mistakes.

The Stakes: A $370 Billion Market

The U.S. foodservice distribution market represents approximately $370 billion annually, according to Morningstar industry analysis. The three largest distributors—Sysco, US Foods, and Performance Food Group—control roughly 35% of this market combined. For food manufacturers seeking national distribution, navigating this fragmented landscape requires either substantial internal resources or a strategic partnership.

A specialized food marketing agency provides the infrastructure food brands need without the overhead of building internal teams. However, not all agencies operate the same way—and the differences determine whether manufacturers build lasting assets or create dangerous dependencies.

The Critical Question: Who Owns the Relationships?

Traditional broker arrangements position the agency as the owner of customer relationships, sales data, and distributor connections. Manufacturers depend entirely on their broker's continued commitment. When relationships end—due to poor performance, strategic differences, or changes in agency business—manufacturers often find themselves starting over from scratch.

An alternative structure exists: the managed service provider model. Under this approach, the agency builds and manages a custom broker network for each manufacturer, but the manufacturer retains direct ownership of all broker contracts and relationships. If the agency relationship ends for any reason, the manufacturer keeps their entire sales infrastructure intact.

This distinction proves critical for mid-market manufacturers—companies large enough to require national distribution but not large enough to justify building internal sales organizations across multiple regions.

What Quality Food Sales and Marketing Services Include

Comprehensive food sales and marketing services encompass far more than broker management. Quality agencies provide headquarters-level relationships with major distributors, uniform reporting systems across all markets, and dedicated regional leadership that coordinates local execution with national strategy.

The foodservice channel alone encompasses approximately 5,000 distributors across 65 distinct markets. Building relationships with broadline distributors like Sysco—which reported $81.4 billion in revenue for fiscal year 2025 and serves approximately 730,000 customer locations—requires specialized expertise and established connections.

Evaluating Foodservice Capabilities

A national foodservice brokerage partner should demonstrate established relationships across all major markets, not just claimed coverage. Verify that the agency has active broker relationships in the specific regions manufacturers intend to target.

Key evaluation criteria include:

Geographic coverage depth: Does the agency have active brokers in all 65 foodservice markets, or do they rely on thin coverage in secondary markets?

Distributor relationships: What is the agency's relationship level with major broadline distributors? Headquarters-level relationships open doors that regional relationships cannot.

Reporting systems: Does the agency provide uniform reporting across all markets, or do manufacturers receive inconsistent data from different brokers?

Regional leadership: Are dedicated vice presidents assigned to specific regions, or does the agency rely on remote management?

Red Flags to Avoid

Several warning signs indicate potentially problematic agency relationships:

Contracts that place broker agreements in the agency's name rather than the manufacturer's name create immediate dependency. Walk away from these arrangements.

Agencies that cannot clearly explain their fee structure or provide references from current clients warrant skepticism.

Claims of "proprietary" broker networks often mask standard industry relationships that any quality agency should maintain.

Making the Right Choice

The right food marketing agency partnership accelerates national distribution while protecting manufacturer interests. The wrong choice wastes years and creates dependencies that threaten business continuity.

Manufacturers should prioritize agencies that operate on the managed service provider model—building custom broker networks while ensuring the manufacturer retains ownership of all relationships. This structure provides the expertise and infrastructure manufacturers need without sacrificing long-term control.

The best partnerships begin with honest conversations about fit and alignment, not sales pitches. Agencies that prioritize understanding manufacturer goals before discussing services demonstrate the consultative approach that characterizes quality partnerships.

This content was developed in partnership with Texas digital marketing agency ASTOUNDZ.

Presenture
City: Houston
Address: 1 Riverway Drive
Website: https://presenture.com/
Phone: +1 713 862 4499