How Immigrants Built America: History To Current Political Scapegoating

Key Takeaways

• The Congressional Budget Office projects that immigration will boost US GDP by $7.2 trillion over the next decade, demonstrating immigrants' massive economic value.
• Immigrants contribute $382.9 billion in federal taxes and $196.3 billion in state and local taxes annually while filling critical labor gaps across industries from agriculture to construction.
• Mass deportations would cost taxpayers at least $315 billion and reduce GDP by up to 6.2%, proving such policies harm rather than help the economy.
• Historical patterns show politicians have repeatedly scapegoated immigrants during economic uncertainty, despite evidence contradicting claims about crime and job displacement.
• From colonial foundations to modern innovation hubs, every major period of American growth has been powered by immigrant contributions.

Immigration Projects $7.2 Trillion GDP Boost Over Next Decade

The numbers tell a compelling story about America's economic future. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that immigration between 2024 and 2034 will boost the US Gross Domestic Product by $7.2 trillion. This projection reflects the reality that immigrants make up over 18.6% of the US workforce as of 2024, totaling more than 31.4 million workers who participate in the labor force at higher rates than native-born Americans.

Yet despite this economic evidence, political rhetoric often paints a different picture. Understanding how we arrived at this contradiction requires examining both the historical foundation immigrants built and the modern scapegoating playbook that ignores economic reality.

The disconnect between immigrant contributions and political messaging isn't accidental. It represents a deliberate strategy that exploits economic fears while ignoring the substantial evidence of immigration's benefits. From tax revenue to job creation, the data consistently shows immigrants as economic drivers rather than drains on American prosperity.

From Colonial Foundations to Industrial Powerhouses

British Colonists Laid an Early Framework for America

America's immigrant story begins with British colonists who established the foundational systems still shaping the nation today. These early immigrants from England, Scotland, and Wales didn't just settle land—they created the legal, linguistic, and governmental frameworks that would define American society. The first successful English colony at Jamestown in Virginia demonstrated the immigrant entrepreneurial spirit, pivoting from failed gold prospecting to profitable tobacco cultivation that built massive wealth.

The Puritans exemplified another immigrant motivation that remains relevant: seeking religious freedom and opportunity. Their settlements in New England established educational traditions, including the concept of public schooling, that became cornerstones of American development. Even today's common foods like apple pie, legal systems based on English common law, and the English language itself reflect these early immigrant contributions that shaped national identity.

German Innovation Shaped American Industry

German immigrants brought technical expertise and educational innovations that accelerated American industrial development. They established the first kindergartens, introducing the German word meaning "children's garden," revolutionizing early childhood education. German craftsmen and engineers contributed to manufacturing advances, while the Studebaker brothers built wagons that enabled westward expansion and later founded one of America's first automobile companies.

During World War I, anti-German sentiment led many to abandon their native language and cultural practices, demonstrating how quickly immigrant contributions can be forgotten during political tensions. Yet German innovations in brewing, food production, and manufacturing had already become integral to American industrial capacity, proving that immigrant expertise creates lasting value even when political winds shift.

Irish and Chinese Labor Built Critical Railroad Networks

The transcontinental railroad, perhaps America's greatest 19th-century infrastructure achievement, was literally built by immigrant hands. Irish workers, many fleeing the devastating potato famine that killed nearly a million people in Ireland, provided crucial labor for railroad construction across the country. Meanwhile, Chinese immigrants, initially lured by California gold rush stories, found railroad work when mining proved unprofitable.

Chinese railroad workers faced particularly harsh conditions and discrimination, receiving lower wages while performing the most dangerous work, including blasting through mountain passes. Hundreds died building the railroad, yet their sacrifice created the transportation network that unified the continent economically. Today's interconnected economy owes its foundation to these immigrant workers who literally laid the tracks for American prosperity.

Jewish and Italian Immigrants Powered Urban Growth

The late 19th and early 20th centuries saw massive waves of Jewish and Italian immigrants who transformed American cities. Jewish immigrants, fleeing persecution in Eastern Europe, established small businesses, entered manufacturing, and played crucial roles in developing Hollywood and the entertainment industry. Despite facing discrimination that limited their access to certain jobs and universities, they built thriving communities and contributed innovations in science. Notable figures like Albert Einstein, who fled Nazi Germany, advanced American research significantly.

Italian immigrants, arriving during the Great Immigration period from 1900 to 1930, provided essential labor for growing cities while establishing cultural traditions that enriched American life. They worked in construction, manufacturing, and service industries, often facing discrimination but ultimately achieving economic mobility through hard work and community support networks that helped newcomers find housing, jobs, and education for their children.

Modern Immigration's Massive Economic Impact

31.4 Million Foreign-Born Workers Fill Critical Labor Gaps

Today's economy depends heavily on immigrant labor, with 31.4 million foreign-born workers filling essential roles across industries. These workers don't just supplement the American workforce—they often take jobs that native-born Americans avoid. Research from North Carolina during the Great Recession revealed that despite 100,000 unemployed individuals in the state, only 268 applied for agricultural work through the North Carolina Growers Association. Of those, fewer than half showed up for their first day, and only seven completed the entire season.

This pattern extends beyond agriculture to construction, hospitality, and other sectors where immigrants provide crucial labor. Their participation actually enables "occupational upgrading" for native-born workers, who move into supervisory and management positions while immigrants handle more physical tasks. Rather than taking jobs from Americans, immigrants often create employment opportunities by expanding economic activity and filling roles that complement native worker skills.

$579.2 Billion in Annual Tax Revenue

Immigrants contribute $382.9 billion in federal taxes and $196.3 billion in state and local taxes annually—a massive revenue stream that supports public services, infrastructure, and government operations. This includes $21.5 billion in federal taxes and $13.6 billion in state and local taxes paid by undocumented immigrants in 2022, who contribute to Social Security and Medicare through payroll taxes despite being ineligible for most benefits. These tax contributions demonstrate that immigrants aren't drains on public resources but significant contributors to government revenue.

The tax contribution data contradicts political narratives about immigrant welfare dependency. Instead of consuming public resources, immigrants help fund schools, roads, healthcare systems, and other public services while often being excluded from the benefits their taxes support. This creates a net positive fiscal impact that strengthens rather than weakens public finances.

Key Industries Depend on Immigrant Workforce

Critical American industries would face severe disruptions without immigrant workers. Agriculture relies heavily on immigrant labor for planting, harvesting, and processing food that feeds the nation. Construction, the largest sector employing immigrants, depends on their skills and willingness to perform physically demanding work. Hospitality, healthcare support, and manufacturing also employ significant immigrant populations who keep these sectors functioning.

During COVID-19 lockdowns, labor shortages in these immigrant-dependent industries led to dramatic price increases, particularly for fresh produce and food products. This preview of life without immigrant workers demonstrated how quickly their absence affects consumer prices and economic stability. The lesson: immigrant workers don't just participate in the economy—they're essential to its basic functioning.

The Political Scapegoating Playbook Emerges

1. Crime Claims Contradict Research on Immigrant Safety

Politicians frequently claim immigrants increase crime rates, but research consistently shows the opposite. Studies examining the 2017 refugee ban found "absolutely no effects on crime from excluding people from the US from those sets of countries." This pattern of fear-mongering about immigrant crime repeats throughout American history, from Chinese exclusion in the 1880s to modern travel bans, despite evidence that immigrant communities are typically safer than average.

The disconnect between crime rhetoric and reality serves political purposes rather than public safety. By promoting fear about immigrant criminality, politicians can justify restrictive policies that appeal to voters' anxieties while ignoring evidence that immigration actually correlates with reduced crime rates in many communities. This manipulation of public fear represents a core element of the political scapegoating playbook.

2. Economic Fears Weaponized Despite Evidence

Economic anxiety provides another tool for political scapegoating, with claims that immigrants steal jobs and depress wages despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Research on the end of the Bracero Program, which sent half a million Mexican farm workers back to Mexico in 1964, found mixed effects on wages and employment for US-born workers. Some studies suggest minimal impact, while others indicate the program may have depressed wages for US-born farm workers. Instead of hiring more native workers, farms mechanized or experienced output decline.

Modern economists consistently find that deportations hurt economic outcomes for US-born workers because immigrant workers help create more jobs rather than taking them away. Yet political rhetoric continues to blame immigrants for economic problems, weaponizing legitimate economic concerns to build support for policies that would actually harm economic growth and job creation.

3. Historical Discrimination Patterns Repeat

The pattern of immigrant scapegoating follows predictable historical cycles. The Page Act of 1875 restricted the immigration of Asian laborers and sex workers, followed by the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which barred all Chinese laborers. These early federal immigration restrictions used economic and cultural fears to justify discrimination that had lasting negative consequences for American development and international reputation.

Modern immigration restrictions echo these historical patterns, with travel bans and deportation threats targeting specific national, ethnic, or religious groups while claiming to protect American workers and security. Research shows that when immigration bans target specific countries, people simply redirect to other forms of entry, making the net effect zero while creating humanitarian crises and diplomatic problems.

America's Future Depends on Accepting Immigration's Economic Reality

America faces a crucial choice between evidence-based immigration policy and politically motivated scapegoating that ignores economic reality. The Congressional Budget Office's projection of $7.2 trillion in GDP growth from immigration represents just the beginning of immigration's potential benefits. Countries that accept immigration gain competitive advantages in innovation, entrepreneurship, and demographic vitality that sustain long-term prosperity.

The historical record shows that every period of American growth has been powered by immigrant contributions, from colonial foundations to industrial expansion to modern technological innovation. Today's immigrants continue this tradition, filling labor shortages, paying taxes, starting businesses, and driving economic growth that benefits all Americans. Rejecting this reality in favor of political scapegoating would represent a historic reversal of the immigrant-powered growth model that built American prosperity.

CRF Publishing LLC
City: Somerset
Address: 149 Irving Ave
Website: https://greatbookscrf.com